Hardly
anyone predicted that the Bush-Kennedy-Kyl-Reid
steamroller could be stopped. But as the New York Times
reported on page one, the "Grass Roots Roared, and an
Immigration Plan Fell."
The American people are fed up with the six years of
"silent amnesty" President Bush has given us by
his refusal to enforce the laws against illegal entry into
our country, against hiring illegal aliens, and against
allowing visitors to overstay their visas. The American
people demanded that Congress reject the 400+-page bill
that would grant Z visas to make Bush's silent amnesty
permanent.
The grass roots showed their power over the White
House, Big Democratic Establishment, Big Republican
Establishment, Big Business, Big Unions, Big Media, and
Big Church combined. Let's consider just one (largely
unreported) of the many terrible proposals hidden in the
crevices of the unlamented Kennedy-Kyl immigration bill: a
surreptitious attempt to convert us to a bilingual (or
even multilingual) nation.
Section 702(b)
would have forbidden the government to
"diminish" any existing rights under U.S.
"laws" that concern services or materials
provided by the government "in any language other
than English." This section was given extraordinary
scope by Section 702(c),
which defined the word "laws" to include
"Presidential Executive Orders."
These deviously written sections would thus have
exalted Clinton's Executive Order (EO) 13166
to the status of U.S. law. Clinton's EO requires all
recipients of federal funds to provide all information and
services in any language requested by any recipient of
federal funds (such as a private-practice physician who
accepts a Medicare or Medicaid patient).
Ergo, all applicants for the new Z visa could apply in
any language of their choice. Applicants would even be
provided with tax-paid attorneys to demand their Z visas
and challenge any rejection.
Clinton's EO 13166 should be repealed and English
should be legislated as our official U.S. language. A new
Zogby survey
reports that 84 percent of Americans support this, one of
the highest percentages of Yes votes ever recorded in
public opinion polls.
CNN's televised presidential debates highlighted the
chasm between the two parties on this issue. When Wolf
Blitzer asked
all the Democratic candidates "to raise your hand ...
if you believe English should be the official language of
the United States," only Mike Gravel held up his
hand.
A few nights later at the Republican presidential debate,
Blitzer asked any candidate to speak up "who doesn't
believe English should be the official language of the
United States." Only John McCain spoke, hedging his
reply by talking about the sovereignty of American Indians
in Arizona.
Blitzer followed up with the question "is there
anyone else who stands with Senator McCain specifically on
that question?" No Republican candidate responded.
A good example of the effect of NOT legislating English
as our official language can be seen in the June 22 release
of the U.S. Department of Agriculture about the school
lunch program. I quote verbatim:
"Please be advised that we have finalized the
process of translating the Free and Reduced Price School
Meals Application package into 25 different languages . .
. Arabic, Cambodian, Chinese (Mandarin), Farsi, French,
Greek, Haitian, Hindi, Hmong, Japanese, Korean, Kurdish,
Laotian, Polish, Portuguese, Russian, Samoan,
Serbo-Croatian, Somali, Spanish, Sudanese, Tagalog, Thai,
Urdu, and Vietnamese."
(Note the discrimination of this list: it omits German
and Italian. Does this mean that (a) German and Italian
immigrants see to it that their kids learn English, or (b)
we no longer accept immigrants from Germany or Italy, or
(c) we are still angry at Germany and Italy about World
War II?)
Univision, the nation's most-watched Spanish-language
television network, has announced it wants to host a
Spanish-language TV debate among the 2008 presidential
candidates. After specifying that all questions would be
asked in Spanish, Univision condescendingly said that
candidates may either answer in Spanish or use a
translator if they answer in English.
Republican National Committee Chairman Mel Martinez
says this is a "terrific" idea. Martinez is part
of the problem that contributions to the Republican Party
have dropped so low that the Party has laid off all its
telephone solicitors.
The Univision invitation illustrates why it is
important to recognize English as our official language.
Since only citizens may legally vote, and being able to
speak English is a requirement for naturalization, there
is no necessity for candidates to speak to voters in any
language other than English.
When a candidate uses a language other than English (as
Mitt Romney is now doing in radio ads),
it's like whispering behind the backs of most voters. This
is unacceptable because the candidate may be making
promises or concessions or innuendoes to a minority bloc,
and because the process tends to divide the electorate
into political pressure groups.
The English language is the greatest force we have for
national unity. It would be a tragic mistake to diminish
it.